"Be curious first, judgmental a distant second."

Title: After Francesco 

Author: Brian Malloy

The Set-up

 “From acclaimed author Brian Malloy comes a stunning novel of love, friendship, and surviving the deepest loss, set in New York City and Minneapolis in 1988, at the peak of the AIDS crisis.” 

More than a decade ago, the organizing principle of our book club was to create a way for us, all former Board Members, to continue gathering on the third Monday of the month to share our mutual love of literature and The Loft.  So, when Linda suggested we read Brian Malloy’s fourth novel, After Francesco, it was an easy, unanimous decision.  

Brian had served as both Director of Development and, later, Director of Education at the Loft before he embarked on a successful writing career. We all remember him fondly, as Steve put it, as “just a fundamentally nice guy and good person, as well as a talented writer.”  With the promise of a “mystery guest,” we were a big, boisterous group including Blanche and Faith, who we’ve been missing, and Chris, who flew in from New York. Liz, Gail, and Joanne unfortunately couldn’t attend and Steve joined by phone to spare us from his bad summer cold.  

From the moment Brian walked into the room to our spontaneous applause, our discussion was off to a raucous start. For a conversation about a novel dealing with grief, guilt, heartbreak, and anger, we still managed to laugh. A lot! 

 

Insights and Opinions

+ Never shy, we dove right into the debate over cultural appropriation in literature. We asked Brian his thoughts about Rebecca Makkai’s novel, Great Believers.  Born in 1978, Makkai is a straight woman who was still a child at the peak of the AIDS crisis. Yet her book on the topic received a $1M advance and was nominated for the Pulitzer Prize. Brian explained that, in his opinion, anyone can write outside their personal experience if they’re writing fiction. At the same time, he thinks it’s fair game to skewer authors who opportunistically write their “emotional truth” in fabricated memoirs like the fictitious bestseller by Francesco’s “sister-in-love.”

 

+ Linda expressed her appreciation for the “gallows humor” that balances the sadness that could have rendered the story unbearable. She read the final paragraph of Brian’s author’s note asking him to elaborate on its final sentence: “Neither man has the self-pitying look of the bitter.”  Brian told us that he realized that he is still angry 40 years later about the cruel mismanagement of the AIDS crisis.  Writing this book helped him come to terms with that anger because, as he said, he doesn’t want to be a “bitter old man”:  “Bitterness is judgmental and narcissistic. It means you’ve given up on other people.”  

 

+ When Brian gave Francesco the memorable line “Be curious first, judgmental a distant second,” he didn’t realize he was channeling Walt Whitman.

 

+ Steve admired how all the characters in the book are fully developed – a skill Brian shares with Faith. It enabled him to care not only about the main characters, Kevin and Francesco, but all the secondary characters because they are so clearly and cleanly delineated. Faith agreed and acknowledged what hard work it is to create such memorable minor characters. When she finishes a novel, she said, she feels like she’s “had a long, long session with a psychologist.”

 

+ A good example of this was our affection for Kevin’s loyal friend Tommy. Brian explained that he was based on a real life-long friend from high school. Brian specifically wanted to include a sympathetic straight character in the book to counter the current demonization of straight, white males. “We’re so into identity politics these days, it’s preventing us from thinking and seeing others.” 

Author Brian Malloy amid the booksters

+ We also all loved Kevin’s eccentric Irish Catholic Aunt Nora. Her continuing outrage at the British government’s involvement in the Irish potato famine created a unique parallel to lingering anger over the US government’s political mishandling of AIDS.

+ Margy found the way in which the details of Kevin’s involvement in Francesco’s death were gradually revealed throughout the book was a powerful way to explain his debilitating and self-destructive behavior.

 

+ Lois commented that Brian has managed to capture the details of everyday life in the 1980s so authentically that it brought the emotional era back to life for her. And, Jocey appreciated his ability to write natural dialogue that “just flows.” 

+ While Kevin Doyle isn’t an autobiographical character, Brian feels he’s done his best writing about him and isn’t ready to let him go. Also a character in his first book, The Year of Ice, Brian is currently planning a third novel tentatively titled Minneapolis is Burning, that will pick up when Kevin is in his 60s (Brian’s current age). Having all loved After Francesco, we can’t wait to return to Kevin’s story and to resume our conversation with Brian as soon as it’s published.

Next Up

Our next meeting is set for Monday, August 16, at 12:30 pm to discuss Turbulence by David Szalay. The author of five books, Szalay was short-listed for the Man Booker in 2016 for his novel All That Man Is. At just 145 pages, Turbulence is “a stunning novel about twelve people and the ripple effect each one has on the life of the next as they cross paths in their journeys around the world." Happy travels!

 

And finally

Many thanks to Margy for writing this post and supplying the pix. And, many apologies to the booksters for the delay in posting because, you know, COVID.